Business Details
20 Years
experience
Your Trusted Real Estate Partner in Suttons Bay, MI
Oltersdorf Realty was founded in 2006 by Vicky Oltersdorf, a seasoned real estate professional with over 25 years of experience in Ann Arbor, Traverse City, and Suttons Bay. Our journey began when Vicky and her husband Mike relocated their family to Leelanau County in the early 1980s after falling in love with the region during a summer visit. Vickys son Jonathan joined the company in 2007 after graduating from Michigan State University, transforming Oltersdorf Realty into a family-owned business. In 2016, Jonathans sister Cayman joined as a licensed vacation rental manager, bringing the teams combined experience to over 70 years. We specialize in residential, commercial, and land sales, as well as vacation rental management, serving Leelanau County and Grand Traverse County. Our success is built on a deep understanding of local markets and a commitment to personalized service.Since 2006, we have closed over 1,000 transactions totaling $385 million in sales volume, making us the top-performing real estate team in Leelanau County over the past 15 years. Our marketing strategy leverages over 50 syndication partners to display listings on 300+ websites, ensuring maximum visibility for our clients properties. We operate from our office at 311 N St Josephs Street in downtown Suttons Bay, where we provide expert guidance to buyers, sellers, and investors. Our teams dedication to transparency, professionalism, and client satisfaction has earned us consistent five-star reviews from clients like Benjamin Fuson and Lindy A Mills. Whether youre buying, selling, or renting, Oltersdorf Realty combines local expertise with national-level marketing to deliver exceptional results.
Services
Real Estate Sales
Vacation Rentals
Property Management
Commercial Real Estate
Land Sales
Details
- Year established: 2006
Highlights and features
- We have over 70 years of combined real estate experience in Leelanau County.
- Our team has closed 1,000+ transactions totaling $385M+ in sales volume.
- We operate as a family-owned business with deep local market knowledge.
- Our marketing reaches 300+ websites through 50+ syndication partners.
- We provide personalized service with a proven track record of success.
What people say
Professional, honest
Go above and beyond
Quick and efficient
Exceptional support
Deep local knowledge
Services
Real Estate Sales
We specialize in residential, commercial, and land sales across Leelanau County and Grand Traverse County. Our team leverages 70+ years of combined experience and advanced marketing strategies to maximize property visibility. With over 1,000 transactions and $385M+ in sales since 2006, we deliver results-driven service for buyers and sellers.
Vacation Rentals
Our vacation rental management services include property listing, guest coordination, and maintenance oversight. We offer access to waterfront homes, cottages, and luxury rentals in prime locations like Suttons Bay and Northport. Cayman Oltersdorf leads this division with expertise in guest satisfaction and property optimization.
Property Management
We provide comprehensive property management solutions for residential and commercial owners. Services include tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting. Our local expertise ensures properties are maintained to high standards while maximizing owner returns.
Commercial Real Estate
Our commercial real estate services cover office spaces, retail locations, and industrial properties in Northern Michigan. We assist businesses with site selection, lease negotiations, and investment property acquisitions. Jonathan Oltersdorf specializes in commercial transactions with a focus on market trends and client growth strategies.
Land Sales
We facilitate land sales for residential, agricultural, and recreational use across Leelanau and Grand Traverse Counties. Our listings include vacant parcels with waterfront access, buildable lots, and large acreage properties. We provide guidance on zoning regulations, development potential, and pricing strategies.
People
Vicky Oltersdorf
Principal Broker
Vicky founded Oltersdorf Realty in 2006 after 25+ years as a top-performing agent with national brokerages. She graduated from the University of Michigan and has been a Michigan real estate licensee since 1983. Her leadership drives the companys commitment to excellence.
Jonathan Oltersdorf
Associate Broker
Jonathan joined Oltersdorf Realty in 2007 after graduating from Michigan State University with a marketing degree. He specializes in commercial real estate and has contributed to the companys growth into a top-performing local brokerage.
Cayman Oltersdorf
Vacation Rental Manager
Cayman leads our vacation rental division, bringing expertise in guest services and property management. A Michigan State University graduate, she joined the team in 2016 and has expanded our rental portfolio to include premium waterfront properties.
Questions
What areas does Oltersdorf Realty serve?
We serve Leelanau County, Grand Traverse County, and surrounding areas including Traverse City, Suttons Bay, Leland, Northport, and Old Mission Peninsula.
What real estate services do you offer?
We provide residential and commercial sales, land transactions, vacation rental management, and property management services tailored to Northern Michigan markets.
How experienced is your team?
Our three licensed agents have 70+ combined years of experience and have closed over 1,000 transactions totaling $385M+ in sales since 2006.
Can you help with vacation rental properties?
Yes, we manage premium vacation rentals with waterfront access and other desirable features in Suttons Bay, Northport, and Lake Leelanau.
How do you market properties?
We use 50+ syndication partners to display listings on 300+ websites, ensuring maximum exposure through the same platforms as national real estate companies.
